Where a species lives is always changing. As temperatures rise, landscapes change and habitats disappear, some species expand into new areas while others lose ground or move towards cooler regions.
Tracking these changes depends on observations collected consistently over many years. In Luxembourg, the data and expertise built up through the Luxembourg Butterfly Monitoring Scheme, coordinated by the Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST) and financially supported by the Ministry of the Environment, Climate and Biodiversity, have contributed to two major studies published in Nature Ecology & Evolution.
The studies were carried out separately, but together they show how long-term and structured national data can help answer questions at much larger scales: where species are moving, what is driving those changes and how biodiversity could change in the decades ahead.
Butterflies on the move
The first study brought together more than 6,000 reports of butterflies changing where they live. They cover 1,758 butterfly species, around 10% of all known butterfly species, in more than 100 countries worldwide. Most of these species had expanded into new areas, while others had lost ground or shifted in elevation. Climate change and extreme weather were associated with 79% of the reported changes.
Luxembourg stands out in the dataset. Along with the Czech Republic, Finland, Spain and Sweden, it is among five European countries where such changes have been documented for at least half of the butterfly species known in the country. The authors stress that this reflects the extent of available evidence rather than the actual proportion of species undergoing change.
LIST researchers contributed distribution data drawn notably from the Atlas of the Butterflies of Luxembourg, which provides a historical view of where species have been recorded over time.
“For each species, we can compare different periods and quantify how its distribution has changed,” explains Nicolas Titeux, Head of the Biodiversity Monitoring and Assessment group in the Environmental Sensing and Modelling unit at LIST. “By combining this information with data from other countries, we can build a much broader picture.”
Luxembourg also illustrates why these changes cannot simply be attributed to warming. Some species that were once more widespread are now largely restricted to the former mining region in the south-west of the country. According to Titeux, urbanization, changing agricultural practices and the simplification of agricultural landscapes have reduced the semi-natural habitats these species depend on elsewhere in the country, making the former mining region the last stronghold for many of them.
Looking ahead to 2050
The second study asks a different question: what could happen next?
Researchers analysed trends in abundance for 265 bird and 144 butterfly species from monitoring data collected in more than 20,000 sites across 27 European countries between 2000 and 2021. They combined these trends with information on climate, land use and land-use intensity and projected future biodiversity trends up to 2050 under several socio-economic and conservation scenarios.
For this work, LIST contributed long-term butterfly abundance data collected through the Luxembourg Butterfly Monitoring Scheme.
The monitoring of butterfly populations in Luxembourg began in 2010 and uses standardized counts at sites distributed across the country, visited repeatedly using the same methodology. This consistency makes it possible to estimate reliably, using statistical methods, how butterfly abundance changes over time. These changes can then be linked to changes in climate and land use and finally used to inform future projections.
The results are sobering. Conservation-focused scenarios improve the outlook for some groups, particularly birds, but none of the scenarios examined is projected to halt or reverse the average decline in common bird and butterfly abundance. For butterflies, the projected benefits of the conservation scenarios remain particularly limited.
Why long-term monitoring matters
For LIST, the value of such monitoring programmes lies not just in producing a national picture.
“We are part of a European network in which data are collected in a structured and standardized way,” says Titeux. “That means observations from Luxembourg can be shared and combined with those from other countries to address questions at European or even global scale.”
The contribution is also scientific. LIST researchers bring their knowledge of local species and environmental change to the interpretation of the results, alongside the data themselves.
The two studies also underline the importance of continuity. Standardized, repeated count over many years make it possible to tease apart natural fluctuations in butterfly populations from long-term trends, and to link those trends to pressures such as climate and land use change.



